passing the "why" argument to log.err is hard and crappy

[radix]

try:
    1/0
except:
    log.err(None, "foo")

or log.err(_why="foo")

trying to pass why= directly causes the following error:

    msg(failure=_stuff, why=_why, isError=1, **kw)
TypeError: msg() got multiple values for keyword argument 'why'

Which is dumb. Either _why= should be renamed to why= or the special passing of why=_why should only happen if _why is not None.

Fixing this ticket should also entail fixing #2567

[Jean-Paul Calderone]

I like log.err(None, "foo") a lot, and I think that was the intended use when the feature was introduced. The parameter isn't named why because log.err accepts **kw and passes them on to log.msg. The leading underscore is an attempt to avoid collisions (perhaps a poor one, but there you go).

I think this should be closed as wontfix or turned into a documentation ticket for explaining this feature of log.err better in the logging howto.

What do you think, radix?

[Jean-Paul Calderone]

< radix> ok